Finals 2025 Week 1

[dedja]

Dimma finds a different way to cook sausages …

[mal]

The Swallow free kick was iffy ?

[daysofourlives]

The Swallow free kick was iffy ?

IMO they dont pay that type of free anywhere near enough, it was there every day of the week

[mots02]

On what possible basis are people suggesting that shouldn’t be a free to swallow?

[another grub]

Just there maybe? , came out in the tackle , tackler didnt know it come out????

Could have easily been let go given the situation and home crowd

[another grub]

Fkcn white maggots deciding games again

[mal]

The Swallow free kick was iffy ?

IMO they dont pay that type of free anywhere near enough, it was there every day of the week

LOOKed at the replay again Daisy
I still dont think it was a sling tackle

[another grub]

Momentum took them to ground and the tackler landed first. 50/50 decision for mine. Id rather it let go looking at the replay and the state of the game.

Im with you MaL. CAME OUT IN THE TACKLE

[stan]

I thought it came out in the tackle, and from that point, it was play on, but it was one of those tackles that he just had him a little too long after the ball came out. It was just the nature of an all or nothing tackle.

I reckon the free was there in the end.

[mal]

Now we have 3 decisions - after looking again it was not a sling tackle
HTB
Holding the man
Ball it up


The one guy who knows about umpiring is AMBAYS
Dedja can you send him a Private Message and get him to post on the matter

[another grub]

Would like his opinion also

[Jim05]

The last free was there but Freo got screwed all game. The AFL would never want an all QLD final would they

Collingwood would be liking their lips though at getting either of them at the MCG

[another grub]

Its rarely you get screwed at home Jim.........

[another grub]

Can we do a survey on this decision please?

[another grub]

I wouldnt be suprised if Freo put in a protest. This could get reviewed and over turned

[mighty_tiger_79]

Free kick was clearly holding the man and been that way all year.

[Spargo]

0/4 tipping this weekend

[mots02]

I wouldnt be suprised if Freo put in a protest. This could get reviewed and over turned

I’m assuming the house was on Freo?

Clear holding the man.

[mighty_tiger_79]

Only seen last 2 finals
Generally the umps let play go and games are umpired better.
But the last 2 were like the other 200 during the season, inconsistent rubbish.

[Booney]

Its rarely you get screwed at home Jim.........

I'm exclusively at home.