Tribunal and other matters

Choccies · Post by **Choccies** » Tue Jul 20, 2010 8:54 am

On the weekend, at half time we asked an umpire to investigate one of our guys getting bitten. Once he was bitten he retaliated with a headlock and was penalised 25 metres. This umpire walked away and refused to even listen to us or look at the proof....... Absolute power hungry fool with no feel for the game he was.... And we were 12 goals up at half time so no real reason to worry about much else...

aceman · Post by **aceman** » Tue Jul 20, 2010 9:39 am

Choccies wrote:On the weekend, at half time we asked an umpire to investigate one of our guys getting bitten. Once he was bitten he retaliated with a headlock and was penalised 25 metres. This umpire walked away and refused to even listen to us or look at the proof....... Absolute power hungry fool with no feel for the game he was.... And we were 12 goals up at half time so no real reason to worry about much else...

Take the issue straight to Barry Oates.

Top End · Post by **Top End** » Tue Jul 20, 2010 9:01 pm

Look for some explosive stuff to be revealed either shortly or at seasons end on a whole lot of topics :oops:

on the outer · Post by **on the outer** » Tue Jul 20, 2010 9:26 pm

NO-MERCY wrote:
Esteban Vihaio wrote:
(S)aintbackline wrote:
how is a player supposed change the way they do something if we cant even get an explanation on why a free was given.

Ask your captain to ask the umpire.

That doesn't get you anywhere either.
Our captain went to the umpire the other week & asked "why isn't it holding the ball when a player drags the ball in on the ground & shows no attempt in getting the thing out, the umpires response was "this aint the AFL this is Amateur League & we don't apply with the same rules"
Thats fair dinkum

that is right that holding the ball rule is the afl rule not in the amateur league rules. it is a very bad rule made by that umpires diretor of afl who should get the sack

NO-MERCY · Post by **NO-MERCY** » Wed Jul 21, 2010 5:34 pm

on the outer wrote:
that is right that holding the ball rule is the afl rule not in the amateur league rules. it is a very bad rule made by that umpires diretor of afl who should get the sack

Bullsh!t, some umpires are paying it & some arn't in the Amateur League.
If you drag the ball in & under & show no sign of getting the ball out its holding the ball.
Great bloody rule i think, your on the outer with your thoughts pal. :roll:

Top End · Post by **Top End** » Wed Jul 21, 2010 6:09 pm

Tonights little show at Thebby could be entertaining from the sounds of it

The Ash Man · Post by **The Ash Man** » Thu Jul 22, 2010 8:55 am

Top End wrote:Tonights little show at Thebby could be entertaining from the sounds of it

Outcomes?

Post by **Footy Chick** » Thu Jul 22, 2010 9:13 am

fizzer - didn't even get heard apparently.

aceman · Post by **aceman** » Thu Jul 22, 2010 9:30 am

Footy Chick wrote:fizzer - didn't even get heard apparently.

How come????? :oops:

Phantom Gossiper · Post by **Phantom Gossiper** » Thu Jul 22, 2010 1:13 pm

NO-MERCY wrote:
on the outer wrote:
that is right that holding the ball rule is the afl rule not in the amateur league rules. it is a very bad rule made by that umpires diretor of afl who should get the sack

Bullsh!t, some umpires are paying it & some arn't in the Amateur League.
If you drag the ball in & under & show no sign of getting the ball out its holding the ball.
Great bloody rule i think, your on the outer with your thoughts pal.

I agree should be holding the ball, and you are right some umpires have been paying it this season, regardless of whether its an "AFL rule" or not, common sense says bad luck buddy your holding the pill :roll:

on the outer · Post by **on the outer** » Sun Jul 25, 2010 9:14 pm

since when can an umpire challenge what some says that umpire should grow some balls and umpire instead of having a chip on his shoulder. this umpire wont go far if he reports for so little and also his coaches should be teaching him to umpire and call it how u see it and to protect the ball player get every head high tackle and let the play flow so the players dont get frustrated. and he should learn to respect everyone and not be a smart ass.

Jimmy_041 · Post by **Jimmy_041** » Mon Jul 26, 2010 3:01 am

on the outer wrote:since when can an umpire challenge what some says that umpire should grow some balls and umpire instead of having a chip on his shoulder. this umpire wont go far if he reports for so little and also his coaches should be teaching him to umpire and call it how u see it and to protect the ball player get every head high tackle and let the play flow so the players dont get frustrated. and he should learn to respect everyone and not be a smart ass.

When its a female umpire?

on the outer · Post by **on the outer** » Mon Jul 26, 2010 9:30 pm

no hosie was reported by the other umpire the little boy.

Dogwatcher · Post by **Dogwatcher** » Mon Jul 26, 2010 9:37 pm

Are you Hosie?

on the outer · Post by **on the outer** » Mon Jul 26, 2010 9:39 pm

Trader wrote:What is the 12 game rule?

Once your total games suspended reaches 12 you're gone for life?

no you have to reapply to amauter league to play again after you sever your penalty at the start of the next season their is no precedent to this

on the outer · Post by **on the outer** » Mon Jul 26, 2010 9:40 pm

no I am not hosie.

(S)aintbackline · Post by **(S)aintbackline** » Wed Jul 28, 2010 12:45 pm

on the outer wrote:
Trader wrote:What is the 12 game rule?

Once your total games suspended reaches 12 you're gone for life?

no you have to reapply to amauter league to play again after you sever your penalty at the start of the next season their is no precedent to this

And more than likely the suits a SAAFL HQ will deny your application

Tribunal and other matters

Re: Tribunal and other matters

Re: Tribunal and other matters

Re: Tribunal and other matters

Re: Tribunal and other matters

Re: Tribunal and other matters

Re: Tribunal and other matters

Re: Tribunal and other matters

Re: Tribunal and other matters

Re: Tribunal and other matters

Re: Tribunal and other matters

the hosie report

Re: the hosie report

Re: Tribunal and other matters

Re: Tribunal and other matters

Re: Tribunal and other matters

Re: Tribunal and other matters

Re: Tribunal and other matters

Who is online