Under 18 penalties.

[ezydoesitbigfella]

And Hefty......look within your own club...

What should I be looking for??

A mirror would be a good start.

[TEX07]

And Hefty......look within your own club...

What should I be looking for??

A mirror would be a good start.

Did you read what he wrote?? He said he is only going by what he was told at the club, there is nothing pending on the SAAFL website regarding either club so all we have is what we are told. There is always two sides to a story, normally one has a large % of truth to it, Doesnt surprise me that any U18 club has issues with boys fighting - its an issue off the field so why would it be any different on the field.

[ezydoesitbigfella]

There's more to the story than fighting - and Hefty suggested it was a Sudanese Broadview player - perhaps he should get facts before making allegations?

[Hefty]

There's more to the story than fighting - and Hefty suggested it was a Sudanese Broadview player - perhaps he should get facts before making allegations?

OK, I have removed my post. Will await tribunal outcome, if infact said incident has even gone to the tribunal??

[Footy Chick]

that's right. Clearly Broadview won't have a million sudanese kids running around either so you can't be tarnishing a kids name if no one has deemed his actions report worthy by way of either tribunal or investigation.

[ezydoesitbigfella]

And Hefty......look within your own club...

What should I be looking for??

A mirror would be a good start.

Did you read what he wrote?? He said he is only going by what he was told at the club, there is nothing pending on the SAAFL website regarding either club so all we have is what we are told. There is always two sides to a story, normally one has a large % of truth to it, Doesnt surprise me that any U18 club has issues with boys fighting - its an issue off the field so why would it be any different on the field.

My point would be that if he is only going by what he was told at the club - then he hasn't been given the full story.

Fact - no Broadview player reported
Fact - One Golden Grove player reported
Fact - a complaint has been lodged by Broadview - I am told an investigation will take place (and may have last night)

Happy to deal in facts.

[Arch44]

that's right. Clearly Broadview won't have a million sudanese kids running around either so you can't be tarnishing a kids name if no one has deemed his actions report worthy by way of either tribunal or investigation.

Why not? Kilburn have a few.

[ezydoesitbigfella]

that's right. Clearly Broadview won't have a million sudanese kids running around either so you can't be tarnishing a kids name if no one has deemed his actions report worthy by way of either tribunal or investigation.

Why not? Kilburn have a few.

What's your point?

[Footy Chick]

that's right. Clearly Broadview won't have a million sudanese kids running around either so you can't be tarnishing a kids name if no one has deemed his actions report worthy by way of either tribunal or investigation.

Why not? Kilburn have a few.

As usual, you've completely missed the point Arch

[Arch44]

that's right. Clearly Broadview won't have a million sudanese kids running around either so you can't be tarnishing a kids name if no one has deemed his actions report worthy by way of either tribunal or investigation.

Why not? Kilburn have a few.

As usual, you've completely missed the point Arch

Nah not at all just trolling

[Footy Chick]

KW

[Arch44]

KW

Not as much any more too many that do that now

[ezydoesitbigfella]

I apologise to Hefty and Tex - I was not informed correctly - there was NO Golden Grove player reported. There WAS a Broadview player reported and subsequently punished. No idea of how the tribunal set penalties.

ROCS Div 1 Reserves player - Intentional - High - Low Grade - 2 weeks
Broadview U/18 - Reckless - High - Low Grade - 3 weeks?

I heard there was an investigation into the incident that may have lead to the report - but nothing showing on website.

Just dealing with facts.

[TEX07]

I apologise to Hefty and Tex - I was not informed correctly - there was NO Golden Grove player reported. There WAS a Broadview player reported and subsequently punished. No idea of how the tribunal set penalties.

ROCS Div 1 Reserves player - Intentional - High - Low Grade - 2 weeks
Broadview U/18 - Reckless - High - Low Grade - 3 weeks?

I heard there was an investigation into the incident that may have lead to the report - but nothing showing on website.

Just dealing with facts.

No need to apologise I hadnt heard anything at all about any incedent at the club - I was actually just pointing out that Hefty was dealing with the info second hand also, you are correct pretty hard to comment without fact.

[S Demon]

My point would be that if he is only going by what he was told at the club - then he hasn't been given the full story.

Fact - no Broadview player reported
Fact - One Golden Grove player reported
Fact - a complaint has been lodged by Broadview - I am told an investigation will take place (and may have last night)

Happy to deal in facts.

I apologise to Hefty and Tex - I was not informed correctly - there was NO Golden Grove player reported. There WAS a Broadview player reported and subsequently punished. No idea of how the tribunal set penalties.

ROCS Div 1 Reserves player - Intentional - High - Low Grade - 2 weeks
Broadview U/18 - Reckless - High - Low Grade - 3 weeks?

I heard there was an investigation into the incident that may have lead to the report - but nothing showing on website.

Just dealing with facts.

I'm confused. That's a fact.

[Blackwhite]

Few huge games this week in the U18's to finish off the minor round. Will Geppies or Broadies round out the top 5? Either team on there day is a threat.