INS and OUTS for 2024

[dedja]

Amazed that he made it out of Footy Park alive that day.

[Jim05]

Amazed that he made it out of Footy Park alive that day.

He was safely celebrating in our changerooms after the game

[Pseudo]

Yes,
It’s been a huge off season for Westies.
Recruited Searle, Wilson who will probably miss 3 quarters of the season and a bloke from Norwood who is injured too……

So 3 ins and about 12 outs for a club on a 5 year wooden spoon streak!

The record for SANFL consecutive wooden spoons is Sturt with 8 (1989–1996), so you're not far off

Thanks for raising that stat... triggered my PTSD Don't want to throw in 1978 to finish me off

Is Des Foster still alive?

A Sturt-Norwood grand final is a distinct possibility this year, to my thinking.

If it happens they should get Des to toss the coin.

[dedja]

Amazed that he made it out of Footy Park alive that day.

He was safely celebrating in our changerooms after the game

I tried to get Gags a while ago to admit Foster faarked up, but he just laughed and said he was a great umpire.

[mal]

https://youtu.be/8q3u_7YN_h4?si=Mcg72A2SaQInAsQR

Watch the first 50 seconds and judge for yourself about the Gallagher free kick

[dedja]

It wasn’t a free, he paid a mark.

Will go down as one of the most fateful and worst decisions in history.

[northerner]

Dogs adding one more to the list today, officially announcing Kade Dittmar, a 188cm 20yo mid/defender who has clocked up 33 games with East Perth.
He is the son of ex Port player Mark Dittmar.

[am Bays]

It wasn’t a free, he paid a mark.

Will go down as one of the most fateful and worst decisions in history.

Could have paid a 15 m penalty based on Howard’s dissent which would’ve put him in the crowd….

In Foster’s defence it did go 10 yards pity we were metric by then…

[dedja]

It wasn’t a free, he paid a mark.

Will go down as one of the most fateful and worst decisions in history.

Could have paid a 15 m penalty based on Howard’s dissent which would’ve put him in the crowd….

In Foster’s defence it did go 10 yards pity we were metric by then…

No-one cares about your maggots solidarity

[mal]

I didn't realise it was a mark
I thought a Sturt player tackled Gags without the footy
Lucky my 2 Glenelg mates on this site knew the decision , other posters might have ridiculed me !

[locky801]

I didn't realise it was a mark
I thought a Sturt player tackled Gags without the footy
Lucky my 2 Glenelg mates on this site knew the decision , other posters might have ridiculed me !

Surely it got sent upstairs for a review

[nwdfanparade]

If Sturt kicked straight ...

1978 grand final match summary 2.jpg (188.16 KiB) Viewed 5963 times

A lot of those behinds (minor scores) were from standing shots at goal, only a few were from kicks on the run under pressure. Sturt had an almost 5 goal lead at 3/4 quarter time despite kicking inaccurately. Surely Sturt have only themselves to blame for the 1978 GF loss.

[southernbulldog]

Dont know what all this has to do with Ins & Outs

[dedja]

Dont know what all this has to do with Ins & Outs

[nwdfanparade]

Dont know what all this has to do with Ins & Outs

Other comments were made about the 1978 GF so I decided to add to those comments.

[northerner]

Dogs adding one more to the list today, officially announcing Kade Dittmar, a 188cm 20yo mid/defender who has clocked up 33 games with East Perth.
He is the son of ex Port player Mark Dittmar.

This brings to total 9 recruits, with all but Kai Pudney from interstate.
A good haul, especially since just 3 of our Finals campaign side are not returning (Hoskin, Linke and Dahms)
This group is made up mostly of mids with pace as an attribute across the group.
Two tall but raw ruckmen are in the list; these are seen as longer term prospects and should benefit (along with Pickering) with coaching from Buckets McKenzie.

Not quite Glenelgs list but will be around the mark...

[whufc]

Dogs adding one more to the list today, officially announcing Kade Dittmar, a 188cm 20yo mid/defender who has clocked up 33 games with East Perth.
He is the son of ex Port player Mark Dittmar.

This brings to total 9 recruits, with all but Kai Pudney from interstate.
A good haul, especially since just 3 of our Finals campaign side are not returning (Hoskin, Linke and Dahms)
This group is made up mostly of mids with pace as an attribute across the group.
Two tall but raw ruckmen are in the list; these are seen as longer term prospects and should benefit (along with Pickering) with coaching from Buckets McKenzie.

Not quite Glenelgs list but will be around the mark...

Agree. You would think it would have to be finals or bust for Thommo this year.

[Hazydog]

I would have thought finals will be a minimum expectation and top 3 a realistic aim..
Not sure Thommo would be under any sh!t or bust demands though..

[southernbulldog]

Glenelg have a great list again but i wouldnt write Sturt off ,they havent done much with quantity of recruiting
but they have brought in 3 very good players that will enhance their list .

[topshelf]

Don’t agree about our list. We’ve dropped back a bit by not getting close to replacing what we’ve lost, let alone actually improving our list like other clubs have. Disappointingly we’ve lost a few players that didn’t play in the league GF as well, hopefully a few of our reserves players can step up but some of those guys we lost are elite, depth won’t be as good either. Think we’ll be around 3-5 this season. Reminds me of 2020.