Salary Cap Investigations

[shoe boy]

I'm not sure how to interpret this. You don't think the salary cap has worked well, so you think clubs are breaching the rules. Yet you call it a witch hunt for investigating those suspected of breaking the rules? Are they supposed to ignore suspected breaches?
It's one thing to disagree with the rule but your club, and every other club, has agreed to abide by it.[/quote]

Not true , my league may of agreed SFL but my and other clubs within did not agree with the salary cap as it is .

[morell]

Todays Tiser "Matt Turner" Probe into salary cap breaches.

Quote from Matt Duldig "We THINK it has worked really well"
You have to be joking ,this witch hunt is a disgrace to all grass roots football clubs .

Matt and his now army of volunteers who continue to tell all we are saving ourselves from ourselves !!

Matt go back and TRY another way to prop up a very poor product in the SANFL!

I'm not sure how to interpret this. You don't think the salary cap has worked well, so you think clubs are breaching the rules. Yet you call it a witch hunt for investigating those suspected of breaking the rules? Are they supposed to ignore suspected breaches?
It's one thing to disagree with the rule but your club, and every other club, has agreed to abide by it.

Hahah the contradictions are quite astonishing at times.

That's what happens when people think with self interest rather than with rationality.

[Dutchy]

Seems to me the Ammo's are happy with the cap but the country leagues aren't.

IIRC this is what it was all based upon in the first place, the deterioration of the SAAFL.

[jo172]

Seems to me the Ammo's are happy with the cap but the country leagues aren't.

IIRC this is what it was all based upon in the first place, the deterioration of the SAAFL.

Nice troll.

We all know that the Cap was implemented to slow the deterioration of the SANFL, and particularly the SANFL reserves.

My suspicion is that the C9AFL clubs are broadly in favour of it (if at least not militantly against it) is that it only changed the football operations of a small minority of clubs.

[Dutchy]

Call me a troll but agree with what I said?

Ammo's like it, others don't

[heater31]

Seems to me the Ammo's are happy with the cap but the country leagues aren't.

IIRC this is what it was all based upon in the first place, the deterioration of the SAAFL.

Nice troll.

We all know that the Cap was implemented to slow the deterioration of the SANFL, and particularly the SANFL reserves.

My suspicion is that the C9AFL clubs are broadly in favour of it (if at least not militantly against it) is that it only changed the football operations of a small minority of clubs.

IMO it was implemented for various reasons. SANFL player drain, Metro player drain and to safe guard club administrators from themselves when the shit hits the fan and club officials find themselves in trouble with the incorporated body act.

[jo172]

Call me a troll but agree with what I said?

Ammo's like it, others don't

You suggested it was the creation of the Ammos, that's the troll.

[Dutchy]

Never said they created it....anyway play on

[Ditchy]

No doubt the SANFL with help from the C9 AFL created it.
Stops the player drain away from the SANFL and C9 AFL. Everyone knows who created it but its a good rule
All good but. Throw those teams out for 12 months for first conviction of breaches to salary cap

[Jimmy_041]

No doubt the SANFL with help from the C9 AFL created it.
Stops the player drain away from the SANFL and C9 AFL. Everyone knows who created it but its a good rule
All good but. Throw those teams out for 12 months for first conviction of breaches to salary cap

No doubt eh! Another ignorant post
Plus there has been successive nett positive transfers into the C9 AFL for the past 6 years I've counted

[jo172]

What Jimmy said.

A player drain is the last thing that is happening to metropolitan leagues. More the alternative with young men coming to town to study/work as part of the broader urban migration

[Ditchy]

12 month ban for 1st offense and 3 year ban for 2nd offense. Life ban for 3rd offense. Easy

[SATCHEL]

What are peoples thoughts on the ban for players transferring to their non home club in the country. i.e. My home club is Tailem Bend and i transfer to say Willaston or something similar. Seeing that Willaston is not my original home club i will need to wait 36 months before returning to the SAAFL!

[jo172]

What are peoples thoughts on the ban for players transferring to their non home club in the country. i.e. My home club is Tailem Bend and i transfer to say Willaston or something similar. Seeing that Willaston is not my original home club i will need to wait 36 months before returning to the SAAFL!

If the other CFL affiliated Clubs wanted to play ball on the same salary cap for 2017 they agreed to I'd think it was ridiculous.

Given they've gone back on their word it's heavy-handed, but necessary.

[Dutchy]

What are peoples thoughts on the ban for players transferring to their non home club in the country. i.e. My home club is Tailem Bend and i transfer to say Willaston or something similar. Seeing that Willaston is not my original home club i will need to wait 36 months before returning to the SAAFL!

As long as it benefits the SAAFL the CFL will be all over it!

[Fricky]

What are peoples thoughts on the ban for players transferring to their non home club in the country. i.e. My home club is Tailem Bend and i transfer to say Willaston or something similar. Seeing that Willaston is not my original home club i will need to wait 36 months before returning to the SAAFL!

Why would this be bought in? Maybe to help clubs from having to always bring in another 3 point player as guys move around each year.

[daysofourlives]

The SAAFL quite happy to have all the young blokes from the country who move to the city for education/work come into their clubs but the minute they want to go the other way they throw a tanty and want to ban them and the CFL will allow it, the sooner this dictatorship that only benefits the SAAFL and SANFL is wound up the better off the rest of the state will be
As someone said earlier far more players transferring into the SAAFL than out so whats the issue??
Maybe if you got more than Mum and Dad along to watch the amateur hour you wouldnt be so jealous of what the country clubs are offering. Why dont you start charging a gate fee and you to might be able to afford the big dollars the country clubs can

[Lightning McQueen]

The SAAFL quite happy to have all the young blokes from the country who move to the city for education/work come into their clubs but the minute they want to go the other way they throw a tanty and want to ban them and the CFL will allow it, the sooner this dictatorship that only benefits the SAAFL and SANFL is wound up the better off the rest of the state will be
As someone said earlier far more players transferring into the SAAFL than out so whats the issue??
Maybe if you got more than Mum and Dad along to watch the amateur hour you wouldnt be so jealous of what the country clubs are offering. Why dont you start charging a gate fee and you to might be able to afford the big dollars the country clubs can

True daisy fashion.

[Jimmy_041]

The SAAFL quite happy to have all the young blokes from the country who move to the city for education/work come into their clubs but the minute they want to go the other way they throw a tanty and want to ban them and the CFL will allow it, the sooner this dictatorship that only benefits the SAAFL and SANFL is wound up the better off the rest of the state will be
As someone said earlier far more players transferring into the SAAFL than out so whats the issue??
Maybe if you got more than Mum and Dad along to watch the amateur hour you wouldnt be so jealous of what the country clubs are offering. Why dont you start charging a gate fee and you to might be able to afford the big dollars the country clubs can

The current situation is the CFL caved in to 2 leagues on the PROMISED salary cap level this year, but PROMISED the salary cap would be reduced next year. They have now broken that written PROMISE for the second time.
The SAAFL have been trying to get the CFL change the APPS rules to allow bona fide city/country transfers worth zero points since I have been involved with it but the country leagues don't want a bar of it.

Talk about tanties

[daysofourlives]

The SAAFL quite happy to have all the young blokes from the country who move to the city for education/work come into their clubs but the minute they want to go the other way they throw a tanty and want to ban them and the CFL will allow it, the sooner this dictatorship that only benefits the SAAFL and SANFL is wound up the better off the rest of the state will be
As someone said earlier far more players transferring into the SAAFL than out so whats the issue??
Maybe if you got more than Mum and Dad along to watch the amateur hour you wouldnt be so jealous of what the country clubs are offering. Why dont you start charging a gate fee and you to might be able to afford the big dollars the country clubs can

The current situation is the CFL caved in to 2 leagues on the PROMISED salary cap level this year, but PROMISED the salary cap would be reduced next year. They have now broken that written PROMISE for the second time.
The SAAFL have been trying to get the CFL change the APPS rules to allow bona fide city/country transfers worth zero points since I have been involved with it but the country leagues don't want a bar of it.

Talk about tanties

And who willll that benefit, the saafl of course so you can get all the lads moving to the city for nothing. Good on the country clubs for telling them to stick it. Again it would only work one way. As I said, why don't you lift your standards instead of dragging the well run country comps down to your level.