Trade + Draft Period 2018

[The Bedge]

I cant keep up with this trade period, so much going on everywhere!

[woodublieve12]

Swans get Jackson Thurlow from Geelong get pick 70

Geelong fans, you rate this bloke at all?

[mots02]

I'm hoping the crows can be the little guy in this..... but i know they wont be

[Bum Crack]

Swans get Jackson Thurlow from Geelong get pick 70

Geelong fans, you rate this bloke at all?

Nope

[amber_fluid]

Pick 15 and just a good honest half back flanker who has probably reached his ceiling. Not a lot really. Hawks paid unders IMO

You're in the minority when it comes to having that opinion but you're entitled to it.

For all the bagging of Wingard, at a good side with a decent coach he is AA material. Hawks get another steal

Like in '13 and '15 under Hinkley?

He’s not a decent coach, even you would have too admit that?

[woodublieve12]

Swans get Jackson Thurlow from Geelong get pick 70

Geelong fans, you rate this bloke at all?

Nope

Awesome

[carey]

Hawthorn have f..ked this trade big time. Massive overs for Chad. Well done Port.

If you want a super star to come to your club you have to give something good up.

is this a serious post Booney?

Think about it for a moment, look at what Hawthorn have given up for him and come back to me.

They offered burton and 15 you said no saying we want 2 first rounders

You rcvd 15 35 burton and dogs future 4th from hawks

Whilst Coughing up a future 3rd and wingard.

Well played hawks!!!![/quote]


Well played Hawks????

Do you practice being a moron? or its just second nature?

[carey]

Hawks paid way overs

Totally agree.

[Sheik Yerbouti]

The 8 way trade is reliant on Neale getting to Brisbane, this will allow Port ( Wingard / Amon / Burton ), Fremantle ( Neale / Hogan ), Brisbane ( Neale / Adams / Beams ), Hawthorn ( Burton / Wingard / Amon ), Bulldogs ( Adams ), Gold Coast ( May ), Collingwood ( Beams ) and Melbourne ( Hogan / May ) to shuffle players and picks.

It's expected Port could end up with Brisbane's pick 5, Hawthorn's pick 15 and Ryan Burton and give up pick 6 and Wingard ( along with something else, future 3rd/4th rounder ).

If Port can end up with 5,10,15 and Burton after losing Wingard, Polec, Pittard ( boohoo ), Amon whilst not thrilled at one of our losses ( Wingard ) I'll be happy that we've got the best possible outcome for our club.

3 picks in the top 15 and Ryan Burton. Not many clubs would knock back compensation like that.

Good compensation that's for sure but a step backwards. You will pick up some very handy players in the draft but they want have the same impact as a Polec or Wingard for a few years. For a team that topped up with experience players last season to challenge it's not ideal but a decent outcome considering.

Bullshit, got rid of Pittard & got a pick under 179, huge win.

[Booney]

Tim Kelly is still a Cat. As recently as today he was on the phone to the cats, pleading with them to allow him to break his contract and return to Western Australia. The Cats are still holding firm.

They're the big ones that are keeping us intrigued.

Don't go anywhere.

[woodublieve12]

Tim Kelly is still a Cat. As recently as today he was on the phone to the cats, pleading with them to allow him to break his contract and return to Western Australia. The Cats are still holding firm.

They're the big ones that are keeping us intrigued.

Don't go anywhere.

Not sure if true but i saw today the Shiels one isn't a done deal yet???

[Booney]

GWS CEO Matthews on Shiel "We're in a good position with Shiel... He's a contracted player so if the deal doesn't get done he'll play with us next year.

[woodublieve12]

GWS CEO Matthews on Shiel "We're in a good position with Shiel... He's a contracted player so if the deal doesn't get done he'll play with us next year.

so there is a small chance he could be a swan by the end of the day?

[bertiebeatle]

GWS CEO Matthews on Shiel "We're in a good position with Shiel... He's a contracted player so if the deal doesn't get done he'll play with us next year.

so there is a small chance he could be a swan by the end of the day?

I've got a feeling he may end up at Carlton yet, going to be an interesting few hrs

[Booney]

GWS CEO Matthews on Shiel "We're in a good position with Shiel... He's a contracted player so if the deal doesn't get done he'll play with us next year.

so there is a small chance he could be a swan by the end of the day?

No. None.

I see the Matthews had a sulk about the COLA too.

[PatowalongaPirate]

GWS CEO Matthews on Shiel "We're in a good position with Shiel... He's a contracted player so if the deal doesn't get done he'll play with us next year.

so there is a small chance he could be a swan by the end of the day?

Not sure Sydney could fit them in their Cap after landing boom recruits Clarke and Thurlow.

[Jim05]

GWS CEO Matthews on Shiel "We're in a good position with Shiel... He's a contracted player so if the deal doesn't get done he'll play with us next year.

so there is a small chance he could be a swan by the end of the day?

I've got a feeling he may end up at Carlton yet, going to be an interesting few hrs

Possibly.
We won’t be budging on our offer I’d imagine.

[Bum Crack]

Tim Kelly is still a Cat. As recently as today he was on the phone to the cats, pleading with them to allow him to break his contract and return to Western Australia. The Cats are still holding firm.

They're the big ones that are keeping us intrigued.

Don't go anywhere.

Good on em for sticking their ground.

[Splinter]

GWS CEO Matthews on Shiel "We're in a good position with Shiel... He's a contracted player so if the deal doesn't get done he'll play with us next year.

so there is a small chance he could be a swan by the end of the day?

I've got a feeling he may end up at Carlton yet, going to be an interesting few hrs

Possibly.
We won’t be budging on our offer I’d imagine.

What's the offer at the moment Jim?
And how did you hope we would get #19 too?

[woodublieve12]

Swans apparently in talks with the Dogs over Liberatore.