Trader wrote:Anyone know much about Marnus? Some people say he's an up and coming gun, others point to the fact he averaged in the 30s last shield season.
Second in the runs last season with an average of 39.75.
Had this discussion with someone on here a while ago about Labuschagne, comparing his last two years with Paterson as to who was next in line IIRC, and while I'm glad he's given a chance, ideally his numbers are just solid from which to launch a bumper year to put himself in the selection discussion. GUess that is an indication of the cricket landscape these days.
Also, still not sure why they don't think Burns isn't worth a long-term go in the middle order.
Good to see Renshaw back though, why they made him fight for his place when he so so much character in India I don't know.
SA bias obviously but If you are going on form from last year Nick Winter, chad sayers, Ferg all could be in this squad. looking at form from england though Siddle has deserved his spot. Finch's all round form has been good i think he can take that into red ball cricket, i would let him go like we did with warner when he was coming in we could be onto something. i think he needs to be up the order if thats the case though. maxy is a tough call if travis gets a chance and takes it i think we are not going to see maxwell in test cricket again. Nesser is a t20 specialist leave him there.
So apparently cricket Australia told maxwell to not play county cricket to rest up and get himself right for the australia a tour and the test matches and he was left out of both squads
PatowalongaPirate wrote:I think Finch will open and Usman at 3. They aren't going to take Finch and not play him, he's not in the squad to gain touring experience.
His best spot is opening the batting so it makes sense.
bennymacca wrote:So apparently cricket Australia told maxwell to not play county cricket to rest up and get himself right for the australia a tour and the test matches and he was left out of both squads
That’s pretty rough
Very rough! Mixed messages doesn't help anyone, very unprofessional.
The Bedge wrote:1. Usman Khawaja 2. Matt Renshaw 3. Shaun Marsh 4. Travis Head 5. Mitch Marsh 6. Marnus Labuschagne 7. Tim Paine (w/k) (c) 8. Mitch Starc 9. Brendan Doggett 10. Peter Siddle 11. Nathan Lyon
That's my guess? Although may be too many lefties, and they'll opt for Finch over Head. Also may consider two spinners in Holland & Lyon but that's unlikely given the depth with batting/bowling isn't great.
Potentially may play Agar as a specialist bat too?
Worse side I’ve seen since the mid 80’s when Border was captain. Mitch Starc the only genuine Test player there.
Oh and Gary.......
I rate Paine and reckon hes the genuine article. After that trio Khawaja might yet be in that category and Shaun Marsh is ok. The remaining six spots will be taken up by guys who would never have gotten close to a baggy green in any other era.
The Bedge wrote:1. Usman Khawaja 2. Matt Renshaw 3. Shaun Marsh 4. Travis Head 5. Mitch Marsh 6. Marnus Labuschagne 7. Tim Paine (w/k) (c) 8. Mitch Starc 9. Brendan Doggett 10. Peter Siddle 11. Nathan Lyon
That's my guess? Although may be too many lefties, and they'll opt for Finch over Head. Also may consider two spinners in Holland & Lyon but that's unlikely given the depth with batting/bowling isn't great.
Potentially may play Agar as a specialist bat too?
Worse side I’ve seen since the mid 80’s when Border was captain. Mitch Starc the only genuine Test player there.
Oh and Gary.......
I rate Paine and reckon hes the genuine article. After that trio Khawaja might yet be in that category and Shaun Marsh is ok. The remaining six spots will be taken up by guys who would never have gotten close to a baggy green in any other era.
Say that again... What era would Paine have been selected in? Absolute joke that this guy is gifted Test matches because they are selecting the Captain before the team. Get Carey in there
Supercoach Spring Racing Champion 2019 Spargo's Good Friday Cup Champion 2020
The Bedge wrote:1. Usman Khawaja 2. Matt Renshaw 3. Shaun Marsh 4. Travis Head 5. Mitch Marsh 6. Marnus Labuschagne 7. Tim Paine (w/k) (c) 8. Mitch Starc 9. Brendan Doggett 10. Peter Siddle 11. Nathan Lyon
That's my guess? Although may be too many lefties, and they'll opt for Finch over Head. Also may consider two spinners in Holland & Lyon but that's unlikely given the depth with batting/bowling isn't great.
Potentially may play Agar as a specialist bat too?
Worse side I’ve seen since the mid 80’s when Border was captain. Mitch Starc the only genuine Test player there.
Oh and Gary.......
I rate Paine and reckon hes the genuine article. After that trio Khawaja might yet be in that category and Shaun Marsh is ok. The remaining six spots will be taken up by guys who would never have gotten close to a baggy green in any other era.
Say that again... What era would Paine have been selected in? Absolute joke that this guy is gifted Test matches because they are selecting the Captain before the team. Get Carey in there
Agree re Alex Carey... he is going to be a ten year player. A class act. But Tim Paine IS a very good keeper; was before his horror finger injury and still is. And right at this moment, his calmness, maturity and diplomacy is just what is required whilst the ethos of the team is being remodeled. And as to what era would he have been selected in? He was selected in 2010 when we were still a decent outfit, and was definitely up to the job.
The Bedge wrote:1. Usman Khawaja 2. Matt Renshaw 3. Shaun Marsh 4. Travis Head 5. Mitch Marsh 6. Marnus Labuschagne 7. Tim Paine (w/k) (c) 8. Mitch Starc 9. Brendan Doggett 10. Peter Siddle 11. Nathan Lyon
That's my guess? Although may be too many lefties, and they'll opt for Finch over Head. Also may consider two spinners in Holland & Lyon but that's unlikely given the depth with batting/bowling isn't great.
Potentially may play Agar as a specialist bat too?
Worse side I’ve seen since the mid 80’s when Border was captain. Mitch Starc the only genuine Test player there.
Oh and Gary.......
I rate Paine and reckon hes the genuine article. After that trio Khawaja might yet be in that category and Shaun Marsh is ok. The remaining six spots will be taken up by guys who would never have gotten close to a baggy green in any other era.
The Bedge wrote:1. Usman Khawaja 2. Matt Renshaw 3. Shaun Marsh 4. Travis Head 5. Mitch Marsh 6. Marnus Labuschagne 7. Tim Paine (w/k) (c) 8. Mitch Starc 9. Brendan Doggett 10. Peter Siddle 11. Nathan Lyon
That's my guess? Although may be too many lefties, and they'll opt for Finch over Head. Also may consider two spinners in Holland & Lyon but that's unlikely given the depth with batting/bowling isn't great.
Potentially may play Agar as a specialist bat too?
Worse side I’ve seen since the mid 80’s when Border was captain. Mitch Starc the only genuine Test player there.
Oh and Gary.......
I rate Paine and reckon hes the genuine article. After that trio Khawaja might yet be in that category and Shaun Marsh is ok. The remaining six spots will be taken up by guys who would never have gotten close to a baggy green in any other era.
northerner and af, neither of you rate Renshaw?
I think Renshaw is an outstanding youngster.... not there yet, but will be in time. Due to lack of options, he seems destined to do his apprenticeship in the Test team rather than at Sheffield Shield level.
The Bedge wrote:1. Usman Khawaja 2. Matt Renshaw 3. Shaun Marsh 4. Travis Head 5. Mitch Marsh 6. Marnus Labuschagne 7. Tim Paine (w/k) (c) 8. Mitch Starc 9. Brendan Doggett 10. Peter Siddle 11. Nathan Lyon
That's my guess? Although may be too many lefties, and they'll opt for Finch over Head. Also may consider two spinners in Holland & Lyon but that's unlikely given the depth with batting/bowling isn't great.
Potentially may play Agar as a specialist bat too?
Worse side I’ve seen since the mid 80’s when Border was captain. Mitch Starc the only genuine Test player there.
Oh and Gary.......
I rate Paine and reckon hes the genuine article. After that trio Khawaja might yet be in that category and Shaun Marsh is ok. The remaining six spots will be taken up by guys who would never have gotten close to a baggy green in any other era.
northerner and af, neither of you rate Renshaw?
Not yet. He looks to have the goods and was harshly treated when dropped but he’s not a genuine Tesf player yet. I think he will be though in time.
There are no stupid questions, just stupid people.
Yeah, fair enough fellas. I suppose they thought having an experienced top order of Warner, Khawaja and Smith was the an ideal time to bring him in given there weren't too many other options and how Rogers and Warner batted pretty well together.
bennymacca wrote:So apparently cricket Australia told maxwell to not play county cricket to rest up and get himself right for the australia a tour and the test matches and he was left out of both squads
Steve Smith and David Warner are confirmed starters to play Premier Cricket in Sydney this weekend along with a host of current and former Australia players.
Smith has been named in a Sutherland side that will take on Mosman at Glenn McGrath Oval on Saturday, alongside Sydney Thunder captain Shane Watson, NSW Blues leg-spinner Dan Fallins and young gun Austin Waugh, son of Test great Steve.
Warner will play alongside uncapped Blues batsman Jason Sangha for Randwick-Petersham, who will face a St George side at Coogee Oval that will likely feature Australia quick Josh Hazlewood as he takes another step on his return from injury.
And for Penrith, speedster Patrick Cummins has been penciled alongside Brisbane Heat paceman Josh Lalor to take on Hawkesbury at Howell Oval.
