Ch9 AFL Division 4 - 2015

[wonder_kid]

Totally agree could have got way out of hand not taking anything away from hope valley they won an that's that just disappointed an umpire changed the course of the game ! Happens way to many times these days for my liking

[whufc]

You're a clown WK .

In my opinion even if it was deemed as "clumsy" he has still run past and elbowed him flush in the head at pace, that's going to upset any environment and it was in full view of the home crowd and umpire. The Kenilworth bloke deserved his send off as you can't do that on a footy field however there should have been an initial send off also. A bit of credit goes to both clubs with some restraint as that had the potential to get reallllll ugly.

That's footy and I've seen much worse an incident overall in my 15 years of senior footy. All the best to Hope Valley for the rest of the year.

agreed

It's sad that a bloke running past and throwing a big elbow to the head at pace is still another incident that happens in amatuer footy. I'm not bagging your club just can't believe that there is still that thug element running around every week.

Have nearly finished my first full season of rugby union and have not seen one incident close to that despite the fact the rugby guys smash the living suit cases out of each other within the rules.

[Footy Chick]

That's because in rugby, your head is usually stuck up someone's bum so you can't see anyway

Isn't that the definition of rugby? One guy, pushing 2 guys heads into 3 guys asses?

[Executive Member]

That's because in rugby, your head is usually stuck up someone's bum so you can't see anyway

Isn't that the definition of rugby? One guy, pushing 2 guys heads into 3 guys asses?

Rugby Union

A Thugs game, played by Gentlemen

Rugby League

A Gentlemen's game, played by Thugs

[Hefty]

You're a clown WK .

In my opinion even if it was deemed as "clumsy" he has still run past and elbowed him flush in the head at pace, that's going to upset any environment and it was in full view of the home crowd and umpire. The Kenilworth bloke deserved his send off as you can't do that on a footy field however there should have been an initial send off also. A bit of credit goes to both clubs with some restraint as that had the potential to get reallllll ugly.

That's footy and I've seen much worse an incident overall in my 15 years of senior footy. All the best to Hope Valley for the rest of the year.

agreed

It's sad that a bloke running past and throwing a big elbow to the head at pace is still another incident that happens in amatuer footy. I'm not bagging your club just can't believe that there is still that thug element running around every week.

Have nearly finished my first full season of rugby union and have not seen one incident close to that despite the fact the rugby guys smash the living suit cases out of each other within the rules.

Geez you talk some sh!t........

http://www.abc.net.au/news/2015-07-27/w ... er/6649974

[The Bedge]

Geez you talk some sh!t........

http://www.abc.net.au/news/2015-07-27/w ... er/6649974

didn't realise whufc played international union

[whufc]

Geez you talk some sh!t........

http://www.abc.net.au/news/2015-07-27/w ... er/6649974

didn't realise whufc played international union

Yep talking about what I have seen at amatuer level compared to what I have seen over 13 years of playing and watching senior ammo football

[Hefty]

Geez you talk some sh!t........

http://www.abc.net.au/news/2015-07-27/w ... er/6649974

didn't realise whufc played international union

Yep talking about what I have seen at amatuer level compared to what I have seen over 13 years of playing and watching senior ammo football

So, your comparing 1 year of RU to 13 years of AFL?? Come back to us in 12 years time and then make a comparison. To say RU players aren't dirty is comical!

[The Bedge]

So, your comparing 1 year of RU to 13 years of AFL?? Come back to us in 12 years time and then make a comparison. To say RU players aren't dirty is comical!

He's comparing his experiences with amateur RU to amateur Aussie Rules - and I don't think he's all that far of the mark either..

[Footy Chick]

Let's change the subject by discussing the last 3 games

NOTHING IS CONCRETE.


North Haven/ EP (A)/Hectorville (H)/Hope Valley (A)
Pooraka: Hect (A)/Hope Valley (H)/ WOS (A)
Eastern Park: NH (H)/Glenunga (A)/Kilburn (H)
WOS: Kenilworth (H)/ Salisbury (A)/Pooraka (H)
Hope Valley: Salis (H)/Pooraka (A)/ North Haven (H)
Kilburn: Glenunga (A)/ Kenilworth (H)/Eastern Park (A)
Hectorville: Pooraka (H)/North Haven (A)/ Glenunga (H)
Kenilworth: WOS (A)/ Kilburn (A)/ Salisbury (H)
Salisbury: HV (A)/WOS (H)/Kenilworth (A)
Glenunga: Kilburn (H), Eastern Pk (H)/Hectorville (A)

[zedman]

Let's change the subject by discussing the last 3 games

NOTHING IS CONCRETE.


North Haven/ EP (A)/Hectorville (H)/Hope Valley (A)
Pooraka: Hect (A)/Hope Valley (H)/ WOS (A)
Eastern Park: NH (H)/Glenunga (A)/Kilburn (H)
WOS: Kenilworth (H)/ Salisbury (A)/Pooraka (H)
Hope Valley: Salis (H)/Pooraka (A)/ North Haven (H)
Kilburn: Glenunga (A)/ Kenilworth (H)/Eastern Park (A)
Hectorville: Pooraka (H)/North Haven (A)/ Glenunga (H)
Kenilworth: WOS (A)/ Kilburn (A)/ Salisbury (H)
Salisbury: HV (A)/WOS (H)/Kenilworth (A)
Glenunga: Kilburn (H), Eastern Pk (H)/Hectorville (A)

i think WOS will hold onto 5th and then look out because they are finals specialists and a couple of players have come back into the mix like rusby and pearce and i see sherwood has played 2 games..

heccies and glenunga relegated..that 1 point loss against the kookas has become season defining for heccies..

[Q.]

So, your comparing 1 year of RU to 13 years of AFL?? Come back to us in 12 years time and then make a comparison. To say RU players aren't dirty is comical!

He's comparing his experiences with amateur RU to amateur Aussie Rules - and I don't think he's all that far of the mark either..

Not if you play for Ingle Farm

[Executive Member]

Let's change the subject by discussing the last 3 games

NOTHING IS CONCRETE.


North Haven/ EP (A)/Hectorville (H)/Hope Valley (A)
Pooraka: Hect (A)/Hope Valley (H)/ WOS (A)
Eastern Park: NH (H)/Glenunga (A)/Kilburn (H)
WOS: Kenilworth (H)/ Salisbury (A)/Pooraka (H)
Hope Valley: Salis (H)/Pooraka (A)/ North Haven (H)
Kilburn: Glenunga (A)/ Kenilworth (H)/Eastern Park (A)
Hectorville: Pooraka (H)/North Haven (A)/ Glenunga (H)
Kenilworth: WOS (A)/ Kilburn (A)/ Salisbury (H)
Salisbury: HV (A)/WOS (H)/Kenilworth (A)
Glenunga: Kilburn (H), Eastern Pk (H)/Hectorville (A)

i think WOS will hold onto 5th and then look out because they are finals specialists and a couple of players have come back into the mix like rusby and pearce and i see sherwood has played 2 games..

heccies and glenunga relegated..that 1 point loss against the kookas has become season defining for heccies..

Only 1 team will be relegated from Div 4

[zedman]

i think WOS will hold onto 5th and then look out because they are finals specialists and a couple of players have come back into the mix like rusby and pearce and i see sherwood has played 2 games..

heccies and glenunga relegated..that 1 point loss against the kookas has become season defining for heccies..

Only 1 team will be relegated from Div 4

rams are done then with inferior %..

do you know the ups and downs for all grades from div 3 to div 7 EM?

[Footy Chick]

Perhaps stick it in a new thread and call it gradings 2016 as it affects most grades from 3 down.

[Robb_Stark]

scrub Hope Valley of the list to make finals they will be lucky to win another game

[Footy Chick]

scrub Hope Valley of the list to make finals they will be lucky to win another game

It's a tough one - the things that work in our favour is that NH traditionally don't travel that well on HV oval - Salisbury is an unknown as most of them wouldn't have played on HV oval since juniors but may get a bit lost by the restricted space..

Here's hoping

[Pag]

scrub Hope Valley of the list to make finals they will be lucky to win another game

It's a tough one - the things that work in our favour is that NH traditionally don't travel that well on HV oval - Salisbury is an unknown as most of them wouldn't have played on HV oval since juniors but may get a bit lost by the restricted space..

Here's hoping

Last time I played at HV was 2003 as an Under 17. Last time the clubs met at A Grade level was 2002.

[S Demon]

scrub Hope Valley of the list to make finals they will be lucky to win another game

You just worry about your own backyard champ. Seems like much more interesting things going on up the hill from what I have heard for you to have to worry about us

[S Demon]

scrub Hope Valley of the list to make finals they will be lucky to win another game

It's a tough one - the things that work in our favour is that NH traditionally don't travel that well on HV oval - Salisbury is an unknown as most of them wouldn't have played on HV oval since juniors but may get a bit lost by the restricted space..

Here's hoping

Last time I played at HV was 2003 as an Under 17. Last time the clubs met at A Grade level was 2002.

I'll be at the game on Saturday. Missed the first one. Come say hello after the game and I'll buy you beer.